"Everybody’s a critic!" It might seem like an indeclinable form these days but criticism certainly comes with its inflections. Indeed, the various shades and application of criticism should be more than apparent to anybody who has a general outlook that they believe to be of particular importance. And since the explosion of a multitude of technologies that can sit quite happily in the palm of your hand (whilst at the same time rather nonchalantly open up doors to the rest of the world) everybody can certainly play the part of a critic at their own will - all be it a self taught one. But, unfortunately, what has grown alongside a general principle of unregulated access to information and its 'brother-in-arms' free speech is its more feral relative – untamed opinion.
Opinion, today, matters: there’s no doubt in that. Take the recently past election as an example; this, in fact, is a system of recording individual opinions in order to determine the single belief of the nation as a whole. And it shouldn’t take a political correspondent to outline the general sense of bemusement or indecision that still pervades a country that cannot make up its mind.
But isn’t this the status of the country in general? One that can’t make up its mind; a nation wracked with doubt and indecision? It is certainly the case in the ecological field of interest.
Consider any one thing that is proclaimed to be ‘Green’ or ecologically friendly – renewable energy, recycling, fair trade, ethical production, for instance – they’re all shrouded by doubt. Ask your neighbour whether or not they’d like to cut their carbon footprint, reduce their consumption levels or even generate some of their own power; nine times out of ten you’ll be met with "Of course I do!" That is, until it comes around to actually doing it.
And that’s not to say we’re a lazy or apathetic nation – not at all. It seems that a large part of the British sensibility just happens to be construed in the "proof is in the pudding", "see it to believe it" schools of thought. Or in other words, what your average Briton requires is a working model.
Ecological Validity constitutes this very same feeling but instead dresses itself in a rather starchy lab-coat language. Essentially, for any one thing to have Ecological Validity it will need to have achieved results in the approximate "real-life" situation it will operate in. For instance, in order to get your neighbour to use microgenerational technologies such as Ground Source Heat Pumps (GSHP) or photovoltaic solar panels (PV cells) he might have to see it working in your very own back garden; then a strong dose of keeping up with the Jones’s may be in order. Or even if it is you yourself that needs the ounce of convincing, there are literally hundreds of ecological products and services which are not only cheaper, more sustainable alternatives to traditional models, but they are more than willing to exhibit themselves doing so. Click on the Ecotricity link to see how something as universal as power is being delivered to homes across the country.
Transparency is the key when there’s nothing to hide. So, could it be that a large portion of why as a nation we seem a little confused is simply an issue of clarity? Every body’s a critic, its true. But let’s try and put a more practical spin on things: the next time you feel doubtful, consider the ecological validity involved. It might just be that a ‘Green’ shade is the perfect colouring for any form of criticism.
Posted under Articles, Lifestyle & Fashion
This post was written by Ryan Whatley on June 29, 2010
-->
















